Neal McLeod, ed. Indigenous Poetics in Canada.
Waterloo: Wilfred Laurier University Press, 2014. Vi, 416pp.
http://www.wlupress.wlu.ca/Catalog/mcleod-n.shtml
There
is poetic justice, to use a clichéd phrase, in the fact that just as the Truth
and Reconciliation Commission was beginning its closing events in Ottawa, blocks
away on the campus of the University of Ottawa, Indigenous Poetics in Canada, edited by Neal McLeod, was awarded
the 2014 ACQL Gabrielle Roy Prize for excellence in
English language Canadian criticism.
While the border that divides Canada from the United States has been
rightly described by Thomas King as "a line from someone else's imagination"
(Rooke 72), as a settler woman who has written about Indigenous literatures for
close to twenty years, the reality is that the 49th parallel has led
to false divisions between Indigenous literatures and cultures south and north
of the border; some tribes literally straddle the border. Despite this, and while I am uncomfortable
with the tendency to categorize Indigenous texts based on a Western version of
imposed nationalism, I remain impressed by the thoughtful and innovative work
done by writers situated on the north side of that artificial line, work that
all too often get overlooked in American discussions of Indigenous literatures.
For instance, while Speak to Me Words:
Essays on Contemporary Indian American Poetry (2003) makes a compelling
case for the need to rethink poetry as traditionally defined through the lens
of Western genres, it does not enact the generic diversity or present the depth
and breadth of perspectives that are integral to Indigenous Poetics. Indigenous Poetics builds upon a
foundation of strong connections between writers and scholars—many of
whom work in both worlds—who trust each other and listen attentively in
order to find ways to articulate individually and collectively their visions of
how and what an Indigenous poetics might look like. As with Looking at the
Words of Our People: First Nations Analysis of Literature (1993), a book
that I still return to regularly for its incisive and elegant exploration of
Indigenous literatures, Indigenous
Poetics in Canada promises to radically shift approaches to and understandings
of Aboriginal poetries.
This
book began, as McLeod explains in his "Preface" as a panel at the Ogamas
Aboriginal Festival in Brandon, where the discussion of three
poets—Louise Halfe, Randy Lundy, and Duncan Mercredi—provided the
grounding for both a workshop on Indigenous poetics and the subsequent monograph
which defies, in so many ways, the strictures of academic publication by
incorporating a deeply compelling array of contributions that span four main
sections: "The Poetics of Memory;" "The Poetics of Place;" "The Poetics of
Performance," and "The Poetics of Medicine." As McLeod explains in his
introduction, these sections reflect "an organic and contextualized
understanding of Indigenous poetics" that is grounded in Indigenous beliefs and
practices rather than relying on the "Anglo-môniyâw interpretive matrix" (3).
Paradoxically, the collection is comprised of essays, stories, poems,
and interviews with contemporary Native writers that at first glance appear
decidedly scholarly, complete with Notes and Bibliographies. Ultimately, however, the collection
resists such strictures in form and theme through its inclusiveness by
encouraging readers to look beyond the notion of a "text" and instead employ
the Cree concept of aniskwâcimopicikêwin, which as
McLeod explains, means "the process of connecting stories together" to
recognize the "constant play between orality" (8) and the works on the page,
which are never fully represented when treated statically. As a result, I found myself repeatedly
reading sections of this book out loud in an effort to experience the sheer
beauty of the poems that are included and in order to relish the range of viewpoints
and forms of expression in the collection.
Divided
into four sections that attain balance by facilitating a constant flow between
and among them, Indigenous Poetics
models for readers, Native and non-Native, the diversity and specificity of
this exciting field. The
collection tangibly demonstrates the need to be attentive to the particular nuances
of individual tribal languages, spoken and written, and the importance of
acknowledging and understanding tribal storytelling practices, both historical
and contemporary. In addition, the
collection makes a compelling case for engaging with Indigenous pictographs and
classical narratives, and recognizing that Indigenous poetics are shaped by
carefully crafted and sustained relationships to space and place. As part of the collection's mandate,
McLeod includes several essays in the "Poetics of Performance" section that thoughtfully
explore the intersection of Indigenous and dub poetries in Canada, developing
the concept of "sound identities" and examining how Native and Caribbean
Canadian poets employ precise and often shared language practices to "recover
and reconstitute" their own distinctive voices (Gingell 273). The result is a book that enables
readers to engage with issues thematically and couples creative and scholarly
perspectives to encourage sustained conversations among and beyond the pages of
this single monograph.
The
depth and breadth of Indigenous Poetics is
remarkable and a testament to the energy devoted to this project by the
participants in the initial workshop, the editor, and Wilfred Laurier
University Press. The book is comprised of longer essays by established and emerging
Indigenous and settler scholars and creative writers, including Warren Cariou,
Sam McKegney, Alyce Johnson, Susan Gingell, Jesse Rae Archibald-Barber, Tasha
Beeds, Michèle Lacombe, Leanne Simpson, Gail
McKay, David Newhouse, Lesley Belleau, Neal McLeod, and Niigaanwewidam James
Sinclair, along with shorter pieces by contemporary poets including Marilyn
Dumont, Daniel David Moses, Waaseyaa'sin Christine Sy, Rosanna Deerchild,
Lillian Allen, Lee Maracle. Gregory Scofield. Joanne Arnott, Duncan Mercredi,
Janet Rogers, and Lindsay "Eekwol" Knight. Finally, the collection offers interviews with three key
Indigenous poets, the late Marvin Francis, Armand Garnet Ruffo, and Kateri
Akiwenzie-Damm that powerfully convey how these writers employ playful language
to explore serious subjects with humour and joy. The essays, poems, and interviews often are infused with
Indigenous words and phrases, and while Cree dominates, the movement between
and among Indigenous and colonial languages enacts the flexibility and
ingenuity that is integral to the spoken and written words of these scholars
and writers who so skilfully "re-sound identities for themselves and their
people" (Gingell 280).
The result is a collection that stories and sings its way into
readers' hearts and minds, offering an affective experience that is also
rigorously intellectual. As Duncan
Mercredi reminds readers at the end of his essay, part of the task of the Truth
and Reconciliation Commission has been to gather "stories from the survivors of
the residential school experiment of indoctrination" (21). Those "emotional, gut-wrenching
stories… were told in such a way that they would remain embedded in the memories
of those hearing them for the first time.
They were poetic" (21).
Mercredi stresses the importance of retaining the power of these
narratives through the poetic and urges readers to keep the "heart of the
story" (21) alive by using Indigenous languages and cultivating oral traditions
that put forward Native perspectives in all of their complexities. Indigenous
Poetics enacts Mercredi's call to action by bringing the aesthetic and
political together into a single volume that is worth savouring and returning
to, again and again.
Jennifer Andrews, University
of New Brunswick
Works Cited
Armstrong,
Jeannette, ed. Looking at the Words of Our People: First
Nations Analysis of Literature.
Penticton: Theytus, 1993.
McLeod, Neal,
ed. Indigenous Poetics in Canada.
Waterloo: Wilfred Laurier UP, 2014.
Rader, Dean, and
Janice Gould, eds. Speak to Me Words: Essays on Contemporary
American Indian Poetry.
Tucson: U of Arizona P., 2003.
Rooke,
Constance. "Interview with Tom
King." World Literature Written in English 30.2 (1990): 62-76.