Jeffrey Paul Ansloo. The Medicine of Peace: Indigenous Youth
Decolonizing Healing and Resisting Violence. Winnipeg: Fernwood, 2017. 128
pp. ISBN: 9781552669556.
https://fernwoodpublishing.ca/book/the-medicine-of-peace
The Medicine of Peace asserts that the impacts of complex
historical trauma are tied to the cycles of violence facing Indigenous youth in
Canada, with the Western criminal justice and mental health systems being
complicit in perpetuating further violence. Ansloos (Fisher River Cree Nation) advocates
for a holistic, culturally relevant, and relational approach, versus the
current standard procedures in settler nations such as Canada. Ansloos argues
that youth are "shaped and situated" within the intergenerational violence of
colonialism. Highlighting the disproportionate incarceration rate, growing gang
involvement, and internalized violence (including suicide) it is argued that
cycles of violence are exacerbated by a punitive criminal justice system and
culturally disengaged interventions. A critical reflection on the Canadian
psychology field/mental health system is put forth to foreground
recommendations for holistic Indigenous approaches that would better address
differing notions of self and well-being.
Using a
Foucauldian discursive analysis through a postcolonial lens, and drawing upon
scholars such as Fanon, Ansloos provides an overview of how colonial processes
have caused Indigenous youth to feel culturally inferior and powerless, namely
the politicization of language and binary internalized and externalized
processes of identity whereby Indigeneity is weakness/bad and settler identity is
powerful/good. Ansloos asserts that youth feel dependent and inferior in
Canadian society leading to shame being the dominant framework from which they
view, and ultimately distance themselves from, their Indigenous culture. He
asserts that Indigenous youth are in desperate need of reconnection and
cultural and communal revitalization. The colonial history of Canada plays out
in the justice system, rehabilitation, interventions, and research that fail to
take historic trauma and Indigenous worldviews into account, ultimately harming
Indigenous youth. Additionally, youth are at an intersection of unhelpful
psychosocial interventions based upon an assumed superiority and universality
of Western methods ("cultural imperialism").
Ansloos
calls for the field of psychology to critically reflect on the past and present
impacts of colonization and the need for more communal and restorative
practices versus individualistic and retributive practices. Potential action
steps would include a more relational and contextual approach and the holistic
Indigenous concept of well-being would
replace the prevalent and often overly simplistic, Western views on identity
and cultural factors. Ansloos uses theoretical arguments by multiple scholars
to tie individual psychological health to community well-being. The sentiment
aligns well with many past research studies such as a 2007 study claiming
"youth suicide as [being] a 'coalminer's canary' of cultural distress"
(Hallett, Chandler et al., 394). The findings of the Hallett, Chandler et al.
study indicate cultural continuity factors have a clear correlation to youth
suicide, especially related to language continuance. Specifically, First
Nations communities with a higher degree of native language knowledge had fewer
suicides and communities with a low degree had a higher suicide rate.
The
author advocates for a "critical-Indigenous peace psychology" to be realized
through raising the critical consciousness of settler and Indigenous identities
to the devastating impacts of colonization and reconnecting youth to
"reconstruct a postcolonial identity that is shaped by their own Indigenous
conceptions of a non-violent future" (54). The
Medicine of Peace asserts if youth embody their Indigenous identity, an
identity that is "principally opposed to violence", it will promote an ethical
foundation able to resist colonization (85). Keeping in mind diverse audiences,
a deeper explanation of this statement is needed to combat prevalent
romanticized notions.
In the
final chapter, some "pathways forward" are offered using a Medicine Wheel model;
however, the suggested model is highly theoretical and not overly grounded in a
relational Indigenous cultural context. The suggested strategies would benefit
from consultation from youth, elders, or a more localized community-based
approach with an analysis of past studies/projects that have used a similar
approach. There have been multiple research studies and health initiatives
focused on First Nations communities/youth using various "culturally
appropriate" methods, with the Medicine Wheel being a popular aspect of many (e.g.
Kirmayer, Laurence, et al.; Sasakamoose, JoLee, et al.; Lavallée; Stewart, and others).
Examining existing scholarship would have provided an opportunity to
compare the approaches and findings across the fields of criminal justice,
mental health/psychology, and health and wellness related to potential lessons
that could be used for future Indigenous youth programs. In her 1995 article Peacekeeping Actions At Home: A Medicine
Wheel Model for Peacekeeping Pedagogy, Calliou offers a peacekeeping pedagogy model using the Medicine
Wheel, encompassing racism, multiculturalism, anti-racism, and peacekeeping. As
an example of health-related research done alongside community and youth, the
2016 study "Because we have really unique
art": Decolonizing Research with Indigenous Youth Using the Arts took
similar theoretical arguments to the ones presented in The Medicine of Peace and engaged with Indigenous youth in Canada
on their perspectives of how to do the work of decolonization.
Although
the book puts forth a thorough theoretical foundation, it lacks a research
component or Indigenous concepts that would ground the work in specific
Indigenous epistemologies and/or knowledges (e.g. concepts of well-being). Indigenous methodologies
are mentioned as being salient guiding frameworks to engage in research with
Indigenous communities yet there was no engagement or accountability to any
community. Working in an Indigenous community would have allowed youth and
community members to share their voices and visions of violence prevention and
treatment. Since there was no engagement with First Nation communities and/or
youth, the research would benefit from additional context on the author's
decisions to remain solely theoretical and how this decision influenced and
shaped the work.
Indigenous-led
research in this area is sorely needed. I commend the
author for laying bare such deeply personal feelings and insecurities
surrounding his identity. The complexities of his personal identity struggle
open many of the chapters where the author relives experiences of his
adolescence "wrestle with the layers of colonial shame that entangle me" (64).
The author has obviously thought deeply about his positionality and provides an
honest account of how he, as an Indigenous author estranged from his Cree
culture and trained in Western methods, can unknowingly objectify Indigenous
teachings. This book would be beneficial to audiences looking for an in-depth theoretical
analysis related to the need for youth to reconnect with Indigenous cultural
identity that could serve as a foundation for further research and application.
Tiffanie Hardbarger,
Northeastern State University
Calliou, Sharilyn.
"Peacekeeping actions at home: A medicine wheel model for a peacekeeping
pedagogy." First Nations education
in Canada: The circle unfolds (1995): 47-72.
Flicker, Sarah, et al.
"Because we have really unique art": Decolonizing Research with
Indigenous Youth Using the Arts." International
Journal of Indigenous Health 10.1 (2014): 16.
Hallett, Darcy, Michael J.
Chandler, and Christopher E. Lalonde. "Aboriginal language knowledge and
youth suicide." Cognitive
Development 22.3 (2007): 392-399.
Kirmayer,
Laurence, et al. "Indigenous Populations Healing Traditions: Culture,
Community and Mental Health Promotion with Canadian Aboriginal Peoples."
Australasian Psychiatry, vol. 11, Oct 2003 Supplement, p. S15.
Lavallée, Lynn.
"Physical activity and healing through the medicine wheel." Pimatisiwin 5.1 (2007): 127-153.
Sasakamoose, JoLee, et al.
"First Nation and Métis youth perspectives of health: an indigenous qualitative
inquiry." Qualitative Inquiry
22.8 (2016): 636-650.
Stewart, Suzanne L.
"Promoting Indigenous mental health: Cultural perspectives on healing from
Native counsellors in Canada." International
Journal of Health Promotion and Education 46.2 (2008): 49-56.