Tanya Talaga. Seven Fallen Feathers: Racism, Death and
Hard Truths in a Northern City. Toronto: House of Anansi Press. 361 pp.
ISBN: 9781487002268. https://houseofanansi.com/products/seven-fallen-feathers.
In the Prologue to Seven Fallen Feathers: Racism, Death, and Hard Truths in a Northern
City, Tanya Talaga shares the story of a broken promise between Nanabijou
and the Ojibwe. The giant Nanabijou offers protection and peace for the Ojibwe
as long as they keep secret the silvery metal found in the rocks near
Gichigami, known to the white man as Lake Superior. A Sioux man, taken in and cared for by the Ojibwe,
surreptitiously discovers and steals some of the shiny metal. The Sioux man is
then caught and, with the aid of alcohol, is persuaded to share the secret of
the metal with the white man. As the promise is broken, Nanabijou is "turned
from warm flesh and blood to solid stone," leaving the Ojibwe to fend for
themselves (3). Talaga continues in the Prologue to provide a brief history of
Thunder Bay, Ontario, "a city of two faces" (3). She explains the stark
division between the white and Indigenous communities, Port Arthur and Fort
William respectively. As the white community grew and the fur trade diminished,
Indian assimilation became a white objective to be carried out through
residential schooling. Although more than a century has passed since the first
residential school was built in Thunder Bay, mistreatment of Indigenous
students persists. Talaga writes with precision, grace, and compassion about
contemporary atrocities perpetrated on indigenous youth in Thunder Bay,
Ontario. She writes
To
understand the stories of the seven lost students who are the subjects of this book, the seven "fallen feathers,"
you must understand Thunder Bay's past, how the
seeds of division, of acrimony and distaste, of a lack of cultural
understanding and
awareness, were planted in those early days, and how they were watered and nourished with misunderstanding and
ambivalence. And you must understand how
the government of Canada has historically underfunded education and health services for Indigenous children, providing
consistently lower levels of support than
for non-Indigenous kids, and how it continues to do so to this day. The white face of prosperity built its own society
as the red face powerlessly stood and watched.
(11)
Talaga's account of seven children who
lost their lives as residential school students is as clear and comprehensive
as it is heart-wrenching. Her clarity of prose and journalistic proclivity make
this book simultaneously easy and difficult to read. That is, the fluidity of
her writing does little to ease the dreadful nature of her subject. Talaga
painstakingly recounts the lives and deaths of Jordan Wabasse, Jethro Anderson,
Curran Strang, Paul Panacheese, Robyn Harper, Reggie Bushie, Kyle Morrisseau, all
killed while attending residential school in Thunder Bay. By pointing to the
systemic causes and the lack of governmental funding and involvement that
allows deaths such as these to proliferate, Talaga seeks to offer hope that
Indigenous students can get the support they need so that these atrocities do
not continue.
Talaga highlights those in the
community who work tirelessly not only for the safety and well-being of
students who attend school there in Thunder Bay, but also for justice for those
who have lost their lives there as well. She exposes the aftermath of the
families who have lost their loved ones and their resiliency as they continue
to move forward in spite of the void in their lives of losing a child.
The
book can feel repetitive in places, and Talaga's research has provided a
lengthy list of names of those involved that can be overwhelming. In Talaga's
defense, the occurrences of these injustices and atrocities are repetitive and overwhelming, not to
mention sickening and demoralizing. Talaga provides the kind of awareness that
precedes action and a staunch and noteworthy optimism in the face of adversity
that should embolden her readers. In the Epilogue,
Talaga writes that Alvin Fiddler, grand chief of Nishnawbe Aski Nation and
Thunder Bay resident, continues to work in an effort to provide safety for the
Indigenous children of Thunder Bay, but that he knows "time is ticking" (314).
Every passing moment is vital to the well-being of these children and, therefore,
to the future.
Talaga imagines Fiddler as he
prepares for the Canada Day Holiday and country's 150th birthday in
2017:
He
will be at a powwow in Grand Council Treaty No. 3 territory with his family.
He will be standing in a circle with all the nations surrounding him in
ceremonial dance, and he will be thinking of the children before him decked
out in their beautiful jingle dresses, their bright-coloured ribbons, and
their feathers, and he will wonder about their future and what he can do
to make sure they make it to the final prophecy – the eighth fire. Can the
settlers and the Indigenous people come together as one and move forward
in harmony? Fiddler hopes against hope that the colonial past will be
overcome and that for the good of the country we call Canada, the Anishinaabe
Nation will rise strong. (315)
The
final words of Talaga's important book strike a personal note in the Acknowledgements section as she writes to
her own children, "you two are the next generation: remember who you are and
carry the stories forward" (349). It is only through remembering the fallen and
telling the stories that we can ever hope to escape a brutal and unjust past
and present. This work is important, and not just for Canada. Talaga's attention
to detail and willingness to meet with people and help to tell their stories
serves as the kind of vehicle of truth that leads to healing for Indigenous
people, not only in Canada, but everywhere Indigenous
people are subjected to the injustices of systemic racism and the deleterious
aftermath of colonial practices. The "hard truths" that Talaga shares in this
book are indeed difficult, but she also shares stories of those who are taking
action to prevent further violence against Indigenous youth and stories of
those who are beginning to heal. And Talaga reminds us that where there are
stories, there is hope.
Brett Douglas Burkhart, University of
Oklahoma