Furlan, Laura M. Indigenous
Cities: Urban Indian Fiction and the Histories of Relocation. Lincoln:
University of Nebraska Press, 2017. 354 pp. ISBN: 978-0-8032-6933-0.
https://www.nebraskapress.unl.edu/university-of-nebraska-press/9780803269330/
In her
first monograph, Laura M. Furlan challenges
assumptions around Native Americans that often either render Indigenous people
invisible in cities or depict their urban experience as one of alienation. Furlan instead questions what it means to be Indian in
urban spaces and, more specifically, how the city experience has been represented in Native writing. Furlan establishes that Native authors have been creating
works that demonstrate how Indigenous people can (and do) thrive in urban
environments as well as exploring notions around identity, nationhood, the
histories of people and place, and the false dichotomy between the reservation
(i.e. Indian land) and the city (i.e. non-Indian land). She argues that such
works "reveal that political agency and cultural preservation are possible in
the city" and therefore "represent a new direction in American Indian writing"
(Furlan 3). Indigenous
Cities: Urban Indian Fiction and the Histories of Relocation (2017) subsequently
makes a critical intervention in the study of Native American literature,
history, and culture.
Indigenous Cities focuses on the writings of four authors publishing after the
relocation period: Janet Campbell Hale (Coeur d'Alene), Sherman Alexie
(Spokane/Coeur d'Alene), Louise Erdrich (Ojibwe), and Susan Power (Dakota). Furlan situates the work of each author within its geography
(San Francisco, Seattle, Minneapolis, and Chicago, respectively) and place
history which provides a useful level of specificity. Collectively, these
writings demonstrate that cities do not only figure as dangerous spaces for
Native writers; cities, as imagined by these authors, also offer connection,
agency, and freedom. The monograph is largely
comprised of literary analysis, but Furlan also
explores how the urban Indian experience is represented in art, film, and
photography. This is a key strength of the monograph as Furlan
acknowledges how the ideas she traces in her key texts translate across
different mediums. For example, Indigenous
Cities is book-ended by analysis of the 1961 film The Exiles by non-Native filmmaker Kent Mackenzie. Furlan uses the film to explore the themes of urban Indian
narratives and to problematise the powerlessness often attributed to Indigenous
people residing in American cities. Furlan's academic
background in American Studies as well as American Indian literary and cultural
studies make her well placed to write such an ambitious, interdisciplinary
text.
Chapter One, which considers Hale's The Jailing of Cecelia Capture (1985), exemplifies Furlan's ability to weave together a variety of analytical
lenses including, but not limited to, gender, race, post-colonialism,
transnationalism, and the diaspora. Furlan excellently
argues the importance of Hale's novel and attributes its relative obscurity
(despite a Pulitzer nomination) to "its redefinition of Indian identity in the
spaces outside of the reservation" and to how, according to critics at the time
of publication, the text does not conform to traditional notions of "Indianness" (39, 40). For example, Furlan
identifies Cecelia Capture as a "new kind of Native subject" and argues that
Hale's ground-breaking novel poses "a tangible challenge to the methodologies
and expectations of theorists of American Indian literatures" (40). Cecelia
Capture was one of the first female protagonists in Native American literature,
and gender figures heavily in Furlan's analysis of
this text. Capture's conflicting feelings about the reservation reflect the
psychological problems created by romanticising a space that also figures as a
site of loss and captivity (Furlan 51). Furlan connects Hale's novel with feminist writing more
generally through its exploration of home as prison but asserts that the text
is uniquely Indigenous given how Capture's ideas are coloured by the legacies
of settler colonialism. The healing potential of protest movements (the
1969-1971 occupation of Alcatraz in particular) saves Cecelia Capture at the
novel's conclusion, and Furlan convincingly argues
that residing and moving within cities facilitates the networks and activism
that give Capture the agency she desires.
Chapter Two explores Alexie's Indian Killer (1995), "What You Pawn I Will Redeem" (2003), and Flight (2007), all of which explore
class, displacement, and marginalisation in American cities. Furlan effectively conveys how Alexie's "engagement with
homelessness serves to map his search for meaning in the urban experience" and how
Alexie softens his rejection of the city as an Indigenous space over the course
of his career (76, 85). Within his writing, Alexie makes homeless Indians
visible and, in doing so, points to the histories of displacement that underpin
the expansion and continued existence of the United States. Furlan's
reading of "homeless Indians as ghosts," and cities as the site of a
contemporary Ghost Dance (with the mysterious "Indian Killer" as the
manifestation of Indigenous rage), is compelling (87). Analysing Alexie's
writings alongside Chief Seattle's 1854 speech (in which he says, "[t]he White
Man will never be alone. Let him be just and deal kindly with my people, for
the dead are not altogether powerless.") enables Furlan
to insist that Alexie's ghosts should be understood as having "something important
to say" (Seattle, qtd. in Furlan 87, 88). Geography
and history are key to understanding Alexie's ghosts, and Furlan
argues that Alexie uses them to "ironize the notion of Vanishing Indians" and
to "remap the city by demonstrating how it is riven with past displacements in
the present" (89). Alexie's emphasis on mapping establishes the urban landscape
as a site of resistance and Indigenous history, whether real (in the case of
Chief Seattle) or magical (in the case of the disappearing/reappearing
pawnshop).
In Chapter Three, Furlan uses Erdrich's The
Antelope Wife (1998) to consider how Erdrich re-narrativises
the urban Indian experience and provides an alternative to that presented by
sociological studies and media reports of the 1970s, which over-emphasised
desperation and alcoholism. Furlan situates the novel
within diasporic writing traditions and explores how movement and borders
figure within Erdrich's work. Erdrich's urban Indians are mobile and
metropolitan, challenging the notion of "a fixed Indian identity rooted in the
past, unable to adapt to modern living" (Furlan 165).
Multiple levels of movement exist within The
Antelope Wife and the distinction between forced and voluntary relocation
is key: the Antelope Woman, or "Sweet Calico," is always moving but becomes lost
and homeless through her captivity. Furlan most
explicitly engages with transnationalism in this chapter and argues that
Erdrich's novel "unhinges the notion of Indians as rooted peoples living on
reservations, people with unchanging cultures, and suggests that these
movements and circulations produce new versions of Indian identity" (139). Erdrich's
characteristically rich writing style enables Furlan
to demonstrate how hybridised cultural expressions (such as foodways)
can reveal selectivity and agency rather than loss or disconnection.
The focus of the fourth and final chapter of Indigenous Cities is Power's Roofwalker (2002),
a collection of short stories and essays that defies easy classification. Furlan's reading of Roofwalker smoothly
follows the previous chapter in its discussion of the (re)writing and
(re)telling of history. (Re)writing and (re)telling are common threads
throughout Indigenous Cities, but Roofwalker best lends itself to
explicit discussion of these ideas given how Power's mother figures as an "archivist"
of family and community history (Furlan 191). In "Museum Indians," Power describes
her mother's protest against the Fort
Dearborn Massacre monument which portrays a white woman and child being
saved from Black Hawk, a violent Potawatomi leader (Furlan
184). Furlan situates the monument and Power's
depiction of her mother's protest within the burgeoning scholarship on public
commemoration (which is a highly contentious issue in the twentieth century) and
effectively argues that Power uses her writing to challenge the dominant
narrative surrounding Native American peoples and their histories.
Indigenous Cities makes an important contribution to discussions around what
it means to be Indian in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. The
monograph challenges us to think more carefully about the importance awarded to
the reservation and how stereotypes work to deny Indigenous modernity and
mobility. Indigenous Cities will be
an invaluable and accessible resource for students of American Indian
literature, culture, and history. Furlan's
theorisations of diaspora, transnationalism, gender, place, and history in
urban Indian writing establish that she should be seen as an exciting voice in
American Indian Studies.
Andi Bawden,
University of East Anglia