Marcie R. Rendon. Murder on the Red River. Cinco Puntos,
2017. 208 pp. ISBN: 9781941026526.
https://www.cincopuntos.com/products_detail.sstg?id=277
Marcie R. Rendon. Girl
Gone Missing. Cinco Puntos, 2019. 208 pp. ISBN: 9781947627116.
https://www.cincopuntos.com/products_detail.sstg?id=310
Anyone
interested in crime novels will find Marcie R. Rendon's Cash Blackbear books
extremely difficult to put down. Rendon (White Earth) is also the author of two
nonfiction children's books: Pow Wow
Summer and Farmer's Market: Families
Working Together. In addition, Rendon is involved in theater with four
published plays and is the creative mind of Raving Native Theater. Her first
foray into crime fiction, Murder on the
Red River, won the Pinckley Prize for Debut Crime
Novel in 2018. The novel was also a Western Writers of American Spur Award
Finalist in 2018 in the Contemporary Novel category. Rendon's crime novels mix
mystery, social commentary, and close character study with a deep attention to
place.
In
the canon of American detective fiction, most series featuring Native American
characters and settings have been written by non-Native authors. However, there
are a significant number of Indigenous authors who are embracing the crime
fiction genre. Writers such as Sara Sue Hoklotubbe
(Cherokee), Thomas King (Cherokee) writing as Hartley GoodWeather,
and Victoria Nalani Kneubuhl
(Native Hawaiian/Samoan) to name a few, are using the detective series format
to provide important self-representation of Indigenous lifeways and cultures.
Rendon's depiction of Cash Blackbear is a welcome addition to the genre.
There
is a lot to like about the Cash Blackbear mysteries, one of the most prominent
features being the protagonist. At nineteen years old, Renee Blackbear, who
goes by Cash, is wise beyond her years. After being separated from her White
Earth biological family at age three and forced into the child welfare system,
where she was shuffled from one white foster home to the next, Cash's life has
not been easy. Since the age of eleven, Cash has regularly performed farm work
for cash--the origin of her nickname. Because Cash doesn't know where her
biological family is, her biggest supporter is Sheriff Wheaton, a seemingly
unlikely ally. Over the years he's consistently been there for Cash, and
rescues her from an abusive foster father, securing her an efficiency apartment
so Cash can exercise her independence.
Although
Cash is quite young, she's extremely smart, resourceful, and brave. As a
result, she's an engaging and likeable character. She bucks stereotypes about
femininity as well as stereotypes of the time period in which the novels are
set: the early 1970s. Cash refuses pot, but will drink endless amounts of beer
and smoke carton after carton of Marlboros. She's a pool shark with a
reputation that precedes her, and she's the only girl working the farm jobs.
Her appearance is simple, and she's usually dressed in jeans, a t-shirt, and
her jean jacket. She's not into free love, bell bottoms, or any of the things
her white peers seem so passionate about; for example, she's critical of her
professors because "rather than talk about the day's assigned reading material,
class discussions often veered off into anti-war discussions or debates about
civil rights. Cash wasn't sure what either of them had to do with her" (Girl Gone Missing 30). Cash is
pragmatic, trying to survive in a world that has been so cruel to her in her
short life. And she not only survives, but she thrives. Cash shows her smarts
when she tests out of her English and Science classes freshman year at Moorhead
State in Girl Gone Missing, and she
even wins a state award for an essay she wrote about Shakespeare and Langston
Hughes. But there are also a lot of things Cash doesn't know, which rounds out
her character as a sheltered girl from rural Minnesota. She's confused by the
idea of prostitution, wondering why anyone would pay for sex, especially when
"make love, not war" is the mantra of so many of her college classmates.
Both
Murder on the Red River and Girl Gone Missing are as much diurnal
catalogs of Cash's life as they are mystery stories. Because the reader spends
every moment of each book with Cash--we know when she bathes, when and how she
brushes her hair, the countless cigarettes she smokes, her large consumption of
beer, and her sparse diet of coffee, tuna sandwiches, and Bismarck donuts--it's
impossible not to root for her to succeed. She is incredibly endearing. And
perhaps this could be a criticism some readers might have: that the mysteries seem
secondary to Cash's daily life. However, the primacy placed on Cash is what
propels each story.
In
focusing on Cash's day-to-day activity, Rendon embeds in each novel a subtext
that raises awareness of particular issues that face Indigenous communities. In
Murder on the Red River,
intergenerational trauma, particularly from boarding schools and placement into
the state child welfare system, is highlighted. Because Cash's mother attended
boarding school and because Cash herself was moved from foster home to foster
home, Rendon conveys the lasting impacts that being separated from family and
culture have done to Indigenous people. In Girl
Gone Missing, while the main mystery revolves around the disappearance of
blonde-haired, blue-eyed white girls, Rendon underscores the "worldwide
epidemic" of the "trafficking and murder of women and children, of all races,"
and, in particular, how this issue impacts Native women and girls. In addition,
Cash's brother, whom she hasn't seen or talked to since she was three, shows up
at Cash's apartment; Cash learns he had been adopted by a white family, treated
as one of their own until he returned from Viet Nam, and the family
disinherited him. Through this character, Rendon again portrays the
mistreatment of Native children as well as the imperative role of Native
soldiers, particularly in Viet Nam.
One
of the other prominent features of the books is place. Set in the
Fargo-Moorhead Red River Valley, details and descriptions of the various North
Dakota and Minnesota settings make the Cash Blackbear mysteries deeply
regional. Throughout the two books--and hopefully there will be more, as the
ending of Girl Gone Missing suggests--great
attention is put into illustrating locality. Ada, the Red Lake reservation, Halstad, and the Twin Cities are just a few of the places
the reader travels to with Cash in her quest for the truth. Topographic
information and geographical elements round out the depth of the descriptions
of place: "All of this land, as far as the eye could see was flat because some
giant glacier had shaved it flat while moving north. And every year it flooded"
(Murder on the Red River 20). As a
result, the settings are far from being empty backdrops. In addition, because
the Red River Valley is where Cash has spent her entire life, she knows this
place extremely well.
While
Cash has an intimate knowledge of the land and a close relationship with
Sheriff Wheaton, her dreams and out-of-body experiences are what spur her
investigations. For example, after seeing the body of a murdered Red Lake man
in Murder on the Red River, in her
mind Cash "saw a gravel road with a stand, almost like a food stand where one
would sell berries, but this one had a basket of pinecones on it" (39-40). She
follows these clues, which lead her to the home of the Day Dodge family on the
Red Lake reservation--the family of the man who was murdered. Some readers may
take issue with Cash's investigative process and proclaim that it perpetuates
stereotypes about "mystical Indians." However, Rendon's characterization of
Cash is anything but mystical, and like all the other characteristics of Cash,
her dreams and visions are part of her. They are not exaggerated or overplayed;
they appear sporadically but do help Cash solve the mysteries. Furthermore, her
visions are primarily about place; she must visit these places to get the
information she needs.
Some
may argue that the resolution of each novel is too easy or oversimplified. In
each book, at the climax, Cash finds her way out of nearly impossible situations,
saving the day just in time. With that being said, these high intensity moments
are part and parcel of the crime fiction genre, and provide satisfying,
closed-case endings that are the hallmark of detective fiction. It is good to
see Cash succeed. Moreover, while these books could be read as standalone
stories, Rendon makes connections to Cash's previous investigations, ultimately
showing that Cash is growing and evolving. Cash is not a static character and
at the end of each book, readers want to know what's next for her.
In
all, Murder on the Red River and Girl Gone Missing are excellent novels,
so compulsively readable that they are difficult to put down. They contain less
gore and violence than other crime novels, but this does not prevent the texts
from presenting compelling and engaging narratives that also touch on issues
that face Indigenous peoples and communities. As Rendon states in the author's
note in Girl Gone Missing, "It is my
hope that you, reader, will search farther for the truths once you have read
this story." Rendon's storytelling places her as a prominent contemporary
Native American crime novelist, and there is no doubt that Cash Blackbear has
many more mysteries to solve.
Mary Stoecklein, Pima Community College